Box Hill United entered the Victorian Division 4 in 1925 and went through the season, losing one game and drawing one game, as they became champions and won promotion to division 3 for the 1926 season. This season proved to be just as successful as they once again became league champions this time losing just two games throughout the season. The following year they participated in the Victorian District League, where they finished fourth. The league was then suspended for three seasons before restarting in 1931. Box Hill were once again crowned champions and moved up to division one. After a couple solid seasons placing mid table, the league was again suspended due to World War II.